|
An Art & Anatomy
Tour of Paris A Continuing Education Activity Sponsored by the Vesalius Trust
by Bill Andrews, with Marie Dauenheimer & Marcia Hartsock
Why, you might ask, an art and anatomy tour of Paris? Other than the cuisine and wine, there were many great reasons for the trip. Andreas Vesalius of Brussels, namesake of the Vesalius Trust, studied medicine at the Univeristé de Paris from 1533 to 1536. Vesalius, like other med students, is believed to have learned his anatomy by reading Galen and visiting the abattoirs and boucheries of Paris. Among the many relevant sights we would see are the catacombs, the morphology lab at the Beaux-Arts, and the national anatomy museums. We were also to enjoy extensive lessons in art history at the Louvre and other art museums, as well as at the library of the Beaux-Arts. For current events in medical illustration, we would meet with our European colleagues as they convened the 12th annual congress of the Association Européenne des Illustrateurs Médicaux et Scientifiques (AEIMS). Thus fortified with reason and passports, and coming from airports around the United States and Canada, our goal was to rendezvous shortly after noon on Thursday, October 11, 2001, in Charles de Gaulle Airport. Et voilà! troop leader Marie Dauenheimer, Sharon Ellis, Vicky Heim, Marcia Hartsock and Bob Edgecomb (our new non-illustrator friend), Kevin Somerville, and Bill and Vicki Andrews did congregate for the chauffeured motorcoach trip into the city. Our final destination was the Hotel Le Meridien, in the Montparnasse area of the left bank. At the hotel we were joined by the rest of our intrepid crew: Margot Mackay, Virginia Ferrante and David Aldrich. After check-in, a few of the more perky explored the shops and sights around the hotel. The rest of us learned the French words for "jetlag" and "nap."
Next up, Christiane Loisel, the Proviseur (Provost) of the École, welcomed us all and told us a bit about the interesting history of the school and its mission of training students for careers in the graphic arts. She also spoke warmly of the medical illustration program at the school and the programs faculty, Antoine Barnaud and Michel Gilles. (See sidebar about the Paris medical illustration program by Marie Dauenheimer.)
The Paris School By Marie Dauenheimer The École Supérieure Estienne des Arts et Industries Graphiques is one of four public art schools in Paris. It was founded in 1889 for students specializing in printmaking and related arts. It is interesting to note that the name "Estienne" is in honor of the Estienne family who, under patriarch Henri Estienne, founded one of the preeminent print houses in Paris, circa 1502. Some of the typefaces used by Estienne were designed by Claude Garamond. Charles, one of Henris three sons, was schooled in medicine. Through the family business, he published a modest treatise entitled Anatomia, in 1536. His major work was De Dissectione, published in Latin in 1545 and in French in 1546. Charles would later manage the family business, beginning in 1551. Professor Antoine Barnaud started the medical illustration program at the École Supérieure Estienne in 1991. He and colleague Professor Michel Gilles teach most of the classes. The program is two years in duration, and includes courses in figure drawing and sculpture, as well as medical illustration and medical science classes. A maximum of six students are accepted into the program each year, for a total of twelve students.
Time for the morning coffee break. So, we dropped in at the townhall of the 13th arrondissement (precinct). After brief welcoming remarks by the Mayors aide and the Attaché for Cultural Affairs, we enjoyed champagne and light hors doeuvres. An unusual coffee break custom, but we had no complaints. We staggered back to the École for a truly fascinating tour of some of the academic departments: bookbinding, printmaking, typography, gilding, graphic design, and illustration. The art and craftsmanship of the students were extraordinary. With all the climbing up and down marble staircases, we worked up quite an appetite.
Déjeuner au réfectoire de lÉcole (Lunch, in the school cafeteria!). We dined on a salad of julienne of radishes and kernel corn, crusty baguettes, baked fish in mushroom sauce with roast potatoes, grilled tomatoes and, of course, plenty of good French wine. For dessert there were assorted petit pastries, cheese, and poached pears in vanilla sauce. And to banish the mellow post-prandial haze we finished with thick, black espresso. The afternoon found us back in the 3rd floor auditorium of the École for several interesting presentations. Jean-Louis Besson led off with a look at his didactic illustrations produced for the publisher Gallimard in Paris. Claus Larsen then presented some of the animations and interactive multimedia work done at the medical illustration program in Bologna. Matthieu Lambert , a recent graduate of the Paris program, made an excellent presentation on his thesis project. A quick change of scene for the final presentation of the day lÉcole Nationale Supérieure des Beaux-Arts. We were privileged to have a special lecture by Professor Philippe Comar on the "History and Images of the Human Body." He began with the 1491 work Fasciulus Medicinae by Jean de Ketham, and showed images from the likes of Vesalius and Da Vinci, Broca and DAgoty. It was a revealing look at the changing manner in which the human body has been depicted over the last five centuries. Afterwards, we toured the comparative morphology collection of the Beaux-Arts. In addition to a number of extremely well done ecorchè figures (one sculpted in bronze by Prof. Comar), there were dozens of mounted animal specimens and skeletons. As a souvenir of the Congrès, we each received a paperback copy of Prof. Comars book Les Images du Corps (Images of the Body). It is a fascinating compendium of anatomy, art and history. Later that evening, we all met on the Ile aux Cygnes in the Seine, near the Pont Bir-Hakeim, for the AEIMS gala banqueta dinner cruise aboard the bateau-mouche Captain Fracasse. Champagne cocktails were accompanied by a leisurely passage upriver past the Jardins du Trocadéro and the Eiffel Tower. For dinner, we enjoyed a delicious confit de canard with wild mushrooms and roasted potatoes. The meal was complemented by a tasty Gamay. We glided by the Place de la Concorde and Cleopatras Needle, the Jardin des Tuileries and the immense Palais du Louvre. Serenely and silently, Notre-Dame, the Ile de la Cité and the Ile Saint-Louis slipped past. There were warm apple tarts and more champagne for dessert. All in all, it was an evening of good food, fine wine and great company in the "City of Lights."
Many outstanding presentations were made by students from the programs at Manchester, Strasbourg and Paris. We learned that the educational systems and curricula are different in Europe, but the European students are very bright, talented, and creative. The AEIMS meeting concluded with a heartfelt invitation for members of the Vesalius Trust and the AMI to come again anytime. We all learned a great deal, picked up a few new tricks, made many new friends, and had a wonderful visit with our European colleagues. Maybe it was the hospitalityor at least the wine at lunchbecause AEIMS has several new American and Canadian members. After the goodbyes and hugs, we decided to visit the open-air book fair on the esplanade out in the boulevard. Travel tip #1: never buy lots of neat old heavy books you will have to schlep around Paris for the next week. Travel tip #2: dont believe the travel guide that advises a man to wear his wallet in his front pocket to foil the pickpockets. Sunday morning, overcast, breezy and cold. After yet another tasty French breakfast, we met Madame Marie During, our professional guide for this day of our Art & Anatomy Tour. Madame was a treasurea high-energy, art-loving, natural storyteller with a great sense of humor and enough patience to handle our gaggle. Madame now understands the American phrase "like herding cats." So, we were in excellent hands as we boarded the motorcoach with Madame During. We were headed west out of Paris looking for Impressionists. Along the way Madame gave us a fascinating history-cum-travelogue of Impressionism, the 1874 Paris Salon, the artists and the quaint villages where many of them lived and painted. One of the many fascinating things that struck a chord with us was her assertion that Impressionism was never a "school" of art, but rather a circle of friends who were artists. We would henceforth call our merry band the Tourists. Our first destination was Giverny and Monets garden. Wow! We gained an entirely new appreciation and understanding of the waterlily and Japanese bridge paintings after seeing the real scenes that inspired them. The sun began to peek out from behind ragged, fast-moving clouds as Madame told us of Monets life at Giverny and his passion for gardening and plant collecting. (See sketch of the Japanese Bridge and the gardens by Virginia Ferrante.) ![]() While in Giverny, we also visited the Musée dArt Américain. Founded in 1992 by Daniel Terra, it explores the rich artistic connections between American and French artists. Paintings by Childe Hassam, Mary Cassat and John Singer Sargent were among our favorites. An exhibition of works by women photographers was of special note. No time to dawdle, though, we had places to go and paintings to seeon to Auvers. Auvers-sur-Oise is a quaint and picturesque hillside town. In the late 1800s, it was only an hours journey by train from Paris. Auvers was home or destination for many artists, including Camille Pissaro and Paul Cézanne. We came to visit the last home and burial place of Vincent Van Gogh. But first, lunch. At a Salon de Thé called Les Roses Ecossaises we enjoyed a delicious lunch of magret de canard (roasted wild duck) and a tasty Côtes du Rhône. (See thumbnail portrait of the Gourmand at Les Roses Ecossaises by Bill Andrews.) In case you havent noticed, duck is very popular in France. So is wine at lunch. Madame decided we needed to walk off lunch. First stop: Maison Van Gogh.
We also visited the Musée Daubigny, once the home and studio of Charles Francois Daubigny, friend and supporter of the Impressionists and an Impressionist himself. We walked to several of the sites of Vincents paintings, such as the church of Auvers and wheat fields. Finally, we finished our trip to Auvers with a visit to the hilltop cemetery, where we paid our respects at the graves of Vincent and his brother Théo. Back to Paris and another memorable dinner at a cozy little creperie in the famed crepe district of Montparnasse. I say cozy, because the restaurant only had eight tables and we occupied half of them.
Tuesday morning, crisp and beautifula perfect day to go underground, to someplace dark and dank. Madame During would guide us through the Catacombs of Paris. Madame, a certified professional guide, said that not many visitors asked for a guided tour of the catacombs. We responded that there are not many medical illustratorsso lets go see the bones! Paris had a problemtoo many graves and too little land. So in 1786, the city began a massive project to relocate several million skeletons and corpses to the ancient quarry-tunnels under Montparnasse, Montrouge and Montsouris. The corpses and bones were disinterred and transported across the city late at night, so as not to frighten the spirit out of the living. Over the door to the Catacombs is a sign: Arrete! Cest ici lEmpire de la Mort (Stop! Here is the Empire of Death). We went in, and down and around a tightly spiraled staircase. Some eight stories beneath the streets of Montparnasse, we found bare, dim electric bulbs and low limestone ceilings that dripped waternot a place for the claustrophobic, or the tall. And then we came upon the bones, arranged in macabre and artful stacksfemurs here, pelvi there, and ranks of skulls in between. The bones are grouped according to the cemetery from whence they came. And for each cemetery there is a stone altar for the necessary religious services accompanying the reburial of the faithful dead. Our tour covered just over a mile underground. After the excruciating climb up another goldang set of tightly spiraled stairs (Why didnt I remember to take all those books out of my knapsack!), we were met by large, but courteous, guards who searched our bags for unauthorized souvenirs. It was time for something enlighteningwe were going to the Musée dOrsay. At least we were scheduled to go there, but the museum strike caused Madame During to switch to "Plan B." So, we ended up at the private (and therefore not subject to a strike) Musée Marmottan Monet close on the west side of Paris. In 1932, Paul Marmottan bequeathed his house and collection of Renaissance and Empire furniture and artwork to the Institut de France. In 1971, the Musée Marmottan received from Michel Monet 65 paintings by his father, Claude, as well as the artists personal art collection. ![]() Monets most famous painting is in this museum, the canvas called Impression Sunrise. It is famous because in reviewing this painting in the 1874 Paris Salon, a hostile journalist/art critic latched on to the title and coined the term "Impressionists" to label the new-fangled painters who deigned to break with tradition. The powerful Gare Saint Lazar is there, too, as are several of Monets atmospheric paintings of London. Having seen the real scenes just two days earlier, we were quite excited to see Monets paintings from Giverny of the waterlillies and Japanese Bridge. We were not disappointed. Any reproductions are small, pale imitations of the luminous originals. Also at the Marmottan are many excellent works by Pissaro, Renoir, Sisley and Corot.
Wednesday, cold and gray. No matter, though, as we were running late for a rendezvous with our dear AMI friends Merri Scheitlin-Nordman and Gus Falk. Merri arranged this days activities for us, and first up was a tour of the library and archives at lÉcole Nationale Supérieure des Beaux-Arts. Madams Emmanuelle Brugerolles (See thumbnail portrait by Bill Andrews) and Catherine Mathon, both Conservateurs du Patrimoine, were our guides. They described the origin and history of the library. They recounted how the Beaux-Arts amassed its collections of art from both professors and students, as well as from donated works. Learning beforehand from Merri that we were interested in anatomy and figure drawing, they showed us significant examples from their collections, including original drawings and etchings by Da Vinci, Michelangelo, Dürer, David and Gèricault. They traced for us the changes in how the human form was presented, as well as how figure drawing was taught at the Beaux-Arts through the centuries. With art and photography, they led us from the classic mythological representations of the mid 1600s through the romantic and naturalistic styles of the 1700s to the more expressive and emotive styles of the 1800s and early 1900s. They were also quite pleased to be able to show us an elephant folio by the natural science and medical illustrator DAgoty. We also were allowed to look through the original photos by Dr. Charcot exploring the muscles of facial expression. We made a quick stop at the Beaux-Arts bookstore on the way out, and that knapsack didnt get any lighter. Then we were off to the Jardin du Luxembourg. Merri had arranged for us to see the Raphael: Grace et Beaute exhibition at the Musée Luxembourg. It was superb. In describing the work of Raphael in the exhibit signage, the Italian term sprezzatura was used, which translates to "art which hides art in the interest of a balance between culture and nature." We all agreed, the man could paint pretty good. After a quick lunch at a small creperie, we were off again on footquickly everyone, quicklyto the Faculty of Medicine of the Université de Paris on the Rue des Saint-Pères in the Latin Quarter. We were going to meet Professor Sibin for a tour of the Musée Nationale dAnatomie Humaine. Youll know you are in the right place when you see the naturally mummified bodies of an ancient Parisian couple and child in a beautiful old Victorian curio cabinet. Spry at 82 years of age, Prof. Sibin is the curator and caretaker of the Musée. He holds a doctorate in comparative anatomy. Prof. Sibin is passionate about anatomy and the educational mission of his museums, and he is more than a little concerned about what will happen to them when he is gone. With a sharp rap of his cane on the floortiles and a commanding, "Ici!" he led us through the exhibits. The Musée is actually a collection of three smaller anatomical museums, the Delmas, Orfila and Rouviére. It is difficult to speak of them separately, since they are adjacent rooms on one floor. Basically, the Orfila contains the oldest exhibits, the comparative anatomy collection, and the curiosities and grotesques; the Delmas contains the embryological collections; and the Rouviére contains the bulk of the normative human anatomical exhibits. There are well over a hundred display cases in the Musée, so we will only recount the highlights of the various collections of specimens, curiosities and grotesques. Although these are anatomy museums, they are also museums of modeling technique and technology. There are mummified specimens in various poses and imaginative presentations. There are wax casts and models, papier-mâché constructions, plaster death masks, even some human taxidermy. Most of the pieces are serious academic studies, but some are sideshow exhibits. Most of the pieces are exhibits of human anatomy, some are comparative vertebrate anatomy. Most of the models are one-of-a-kind pieces, some few are early commercial models by the Tramond firm, dating to the late 1800s.
Rosa Bonheurs Studio by Marcia Hartsock Less well-known today than other nineteenth century realists, Rosa Bonheur was one of the most successful woman artists of all time. She gained international fame for her powerful portrayals of animals as well as her independent, eccentric lifestyle. Possibly her most famous painting was The Horse Fair, exhibited at the Paris Salon of 1853, and now part of the permanent collection of the Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York. Bonheur believed that the sketches of her observations were her most valuable resources, not only as references for a particular work, but also to stimulate her imagination. She kept a small farm with stable behind her chateau where she raised a variety of animals, including a pair of lions, her living collection of subject matter. Her large, high ceiling studio contains many framed paintings and sketches, as well as horns and antlers of her beloved animals, displayed just as she left them. Because Bonheur's studio is not a frequent tourist destination, so far there are none of the restrictions found at other famous artist's studios. We had her home almost to ourselves, and could freely take pictures, page through photo albums, and study her paintings and collections at close range.
|